‘Check-up of Democracy’: ministers compare the plot of the coup with the virus during Zanin’s vote in the STF

‘Check-up of Democracy’: ministers compare the plot of the coup with the virus during Zanin’s vote in the STF


The first class made the majority for the condemnation of Jair Bolsonaro and other allies for the coup d’etat attempt

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hp-magmpvsk

For Minister Cámen Lúcia of the Federal Supreme Court, a coup d’état takes place as an internal corrosion. It does not comply with the law within a state of democratic law. It is like a virus: the body is there, but it has a very serious disease and will die. This is the reason why it is necessary to take care while there is only “a sick nucleus” before it spreads and contaminates the whole body. The reflection was made during the vote of Cristiano Zanin, president of the first class, for the condemnation of Jair Bolsonaro in the process of the plot of the coup d’état on Thursday 11.

The topic began to be sewn when Minister Florevo Dino asked the word during Zanin’s vote to speak of the “difficult phase that the democratic regime passes into the world” in times of populism and extremism. The minister even claimed to have taken measures for the attacks he received after giving his vote in favor of the sentence of the defendants in this trial. “Unfortunately, these are things that can earn materiality,” he said, strengthening Zanin’s position that it is important to limit these actions and simply prevent.

Alexandre de Moraes, representative of the case, has defined the phenomenon “new extremist digital populism”, explaining that they are a situation in which democracy no longer attack, but the tools that lead to democracy. Zanin then began to resume his speech by saying that there is “there are tools to guarantee the state of democratic law” and that we have these tools.

Until Cámen Lúcia asked the word to strengthen the problem. The dean of the class, whose vote in the criminal action was the majority for the sentence of the defendants, said that if the coup d’état is not indicted or punished, it becomes an example.

“It does not comply with the law within a state of democratic law. An internal corrosion. It is a virus, also. The body is there, but with a very serious disease and will die. It is insidious, invisible. One day you have pain in the arm, one day there is not … if it is in an expert he will say that it is an allergy problem.

“It’s a control of democracy,” Flávio Dino joked, appropriating the metaphor. “And I hope this judgment is a medicine so that it does not return frequently. The anniversary is not good,” concluded Cámen Lúcia, who evaluates that “the intelligent person takes care of health so as not to treat the disease”.





“What is unheard of in this criminal action is that Brazil pulsates me,” says Cámen Lucia:
  • Frequent

    “What is unheard of in this criminal action is that Brazil pulsates me,” says Cámen Lúcia

  • Frequent

    Bolsonaro is sentenced to 27 years and 3 months in prison for attempted coup d'état

    Bolsonaro is sentenced to 27 years and 3 months in prison for attempted coup d’état

  • Frequent

    Dino reports the threats he received after voting to condemn Bolsonaro:

    Dino reports the threats he received after voting to condemn Bolsonaro: “that I should go to Nepal”

  • Frequent

    Fux is silent and has headed in a session full of jokes and interactions in the ASF

    Fux is silent and has headed in a session full of jokes and interactions in the ASF

More information on the judgment

The first class of the Federal Supreme Court was the majority for the condemnation of the defendants in the case of the plot of the coup. With the votes of the ministers Alexandre de Moraes, Flávio Dino, Cámen Lúcia and Cristiano Zanin, they are condemned for armed criminal organization, attempted violent abolition of the state of democratic law, coup, damage qualified by violence or serious threat and deterioration of equity listed the former president Jair Jair Jair Bolsono (PL); Former Minister of Defense and Civil House, Walter Braga Netto; Ex-assistant ordering assistant Mauro Cid; Admiral Squadron who commanded the Navy, Almir Garnier; Former Minister of Justice, Anderson Torres; Former GSI minister (institutional security office), Augusto Heleno; and the General and former Defense Minister, Paulo Sérgio Nogueira.

Alexandre RamagemDeputy Federal and former president of Abin (Brazilian intelligence agency) which is also the goal of criminal action, is the only one who is responsible for only three of these five crimes: armed criminal organization, attempted violent abolition of the state of democratic law and coup.

The only divergence in court came from Minister Luiz Fux, who voted for the acquittal of Jair Bolsonaro, as well as the defendants Almir Garnier, Alexandre Ramagem, Sérgio Nogueira, Augustus Heleno and Anderson Torres. In parallel, Fux asked for the beliefs of Mauro Cid and Walter Braga Netto – but only for the crime of attempted abolition of the state of democratic law. In practice, however, your vote does not interfere with the process, because the decision is for the majority and the score was 4×1.

The trial started last Tuesday and is its fifth day. The sessions already had the reading of the general report of Alexandre de Moraes, a rapporteur of the case; the manifestation of the attorney general, Paulo Gonet, who strengthened the complaint; and the final declaration of the defense of the eight defendants. This week, the ministers voted for the condemnation, or not, of those involved in the “crucial nucleus” of the state of state coup and,, Now analyze the dosimetry of the feathers.

Source: Terra

You may also like