The musicians have asked for moral damages, but will be forced to pay the legal costs
The Court of Sao Paulo rejected the request for compensation of R$ 30,000 made by the musicians Roger Moreira and Marcos Kleine, of the group Ultraje a Rigor, against the cartoonist Gilmar Machado Barbosa, known as Gilmar. The lawsuit was brought by the artists after three cartoons were published on social media, in which they were called “failed fascists”, as well as Roger being identified as a “racist” and “genocidal boot licker”. The decision was issued by judge Andrea de Abreu, of the XIV Civil Court.
Artistic freedom and expression
According to the judge, the band members are public figures who express their political opinions and, therefore, are subject to receiving criticism with the same intensity. The decision found that the cartoons were based on political positions previously expressed by Roger, such as a post about racism, and that Gilmar had expressed support for a Kiss FM radio host, who was criticized by musicians after calling them “failed fascists”.
Analysis of the cartoons
According to the judge’s assessment, although one of the cartoons had offensive content, it was necessary to understand the context of Roger’s statements to associate it with racism. Regarding the use of the term “genocidal”, the judge found that it was addressed to former president Jair Bolsonaro, while Roger was classified only as “toady”, an expression which, according to the decision, indicated fervent support, which which the author himself has already expressed publicly.
Gilmar’s reaction
Gilmar celebrated the decision, saying it represents a victory for freedom of artistic and journalistic expression. “I have suffered from attempts at inhibition by far-right supporters,” the cartoonist said, arguing that decisions like this consolidate the fight for freedom of expression.
Source: Terra
Earl Johnson is a music writer at Gossipify, known for his in-depth analysis and unique perspective on the industry. A graduate of USC with a degree in Music, he brings years of experience and passion to his writing. He covers the latest releases and trends, always on the lookout for the next big thing in music.
