You on Netflix: This fan theory is a bluff and calls everything into question

Warning, this article contains spoilers for your season 4 episode 1 episode. If you’re not up to date, you risk missing out on what’s next.

A month after the release of You season 4, episode 1 — in which Joe was stalked by a mysterious man — Netflix is ​​streaming the final five episodes.

Our hero, played by Penn Badgley, discovers at the last minute that Rhys Montrose (Ed Splers) is none other than a hitman of the rich. In part 2, he will meet the person who torments him after arriving in London.

If… Rhys only exists in Joe’s head. That’s the theory Fan debunked in an 8-minute YouTube video where he goes through his arguments one by one. And they are almost all acceptable. According to him, the English teacher is really behind all the murders, although he doesn’t seem to remember it.

(Note: the video is in English, but you can activate the subtitles and put the translation in French).

We’re not going to go over all the issues raised in the demo, but one of them is pretty glaring: we never see Rhys address a character other than Joe.

And he is also someone who stands out from the rest of his group of friends. He didn’t grow up in a rich environment, he is A self-made man As someone running for mayor, he shares the same vision as Joe on many issues… In short, the two complement each other quite well.

As for the victims of the serial killer, they are all related to our hero, and each time he had a reason to kill them: Malcolm lied to Kate, he knew Simon was a liar, and Gemma humiliated his employees and had suspicions. him.

If this theory turns out to be correct, it will create a real twist in Season 4, Part 2. And most importantly, this will be the first time you claim that Joe is suffering from psychiatric problems and a split personality.