Cleaning Mrs: Is the Trailer a Faithful Novel? What do internet users think about the first images of the movie with Amanda Seyfried and Sydney Swan?

The cleaning woman’s trailer, adapting the bestseller of Frieda McFadden, was released last Tuesday. The film tells the story of a mile (Sydney Swine), a young woman who is employed by Winchester’s wealthy New York family. She cleans her, cares for her daughter, prepares dishes until she joins her small room in the attic.

For millions, this work is the ability to start from scratch. But beyond the honorable appearance, his boss Nina (Amanda Seyfried) reveals more toxic individuals. And when the miles find out that the door of his room is just locked outside, it may already be too late …

Literary event

Thanks to Tiktok, a real phenomenon has been translated into more than 40 languages ​​and has gone through more than 4.5 million copies worldwide. In France, it was the best sales book of 2024 with 620,000 copies. Based on this success, Freud McFadden wrote two suits on the adventures of her cleaning lady, as well as other psychological triles (“La PSY”, “Teacher” ...). In total, his works in France sold 2.7 million copies.

The secret of this popularity? Final fate. Each McPadden’s book is based on an unexpected reversal that has attracted millions of readers and explodes discussions on booktok. Many shot themselves by discovering the end of the cleaning woman, responding live. And this phenomenon is already repeated with the film: Tiktok, fans of the fans that react to Paul Feiga trailer.

Then, what do readers think about these first pictures?

LionsGate’s official YouTube page, The cleaning woman’s trailer already has more than 5.4 million views. Most of the comments are positive. Casting, in particular, the choice of Sydney Swan and Amanda Seyfried, as well as in the role of Michel Moron, in the role of Enzo. The Winchester House is also faithful to describe the novel. The first pictures also shown emblem scenes, such as the presentation of the tube of Andrew (Brendan Sklenar), obviously not so fascinated, the bathroom sequence, the appearance of the pipe in white, or the discovery of its room.

Disagreement

This is exactly the tube room that makes the most arguments in the comments. In the novel, this work is located in the attic. It is described as shredded and spoiled, dirty and bleached walls.

“There is no other way to qualify for it. Not only this, but also the ceiling is tilted, like the roof of the house, so that the opposite side of the waist. Instead, the huge king of Winchester’s main bedroom, his wardrobe and his chestnut toilet, this small camp, from all the little dressed.” So comment on the novel by discovering a play play.

We know a little bit that the mattress is painted, placed on the framed frame. The small window barely gives the light passing and, above all, the doors are closed from the outside, which immediately creates the impression and trap.

In the trailer, although it seems moderate, the room still looks quite large, clean and bright. The difference that the fans could not note.

“Is this where the pipe room seems much bigger and brighter than what you described in the book? I would always imagine his very small room, parquet and dark wood walls. “Writes Surfer’s comment on his trailer. Another comment:“In the book, the room is the largest alarm signal. It looks more like a prison cell than a room, but it’s not here.”

Up Tiktok, adds to the reader :: “When I was reading a room description in the book, I was thinking under the stairs of Harry Potter.

Is Amanda Seyfried too thin to portray Nina?

Another disagreement: Amanda Seyfried Physics. In the novel, Nina has been described several times as female flesh. Mill compares the photos of his boss at the beginning of his relationship with Andrew, with his current physics. This detail, obviously trivial, takes full meaning at the end of the story. However, Amanda Seyfried is thin in this trailer.

Many readers believe that Nina’s physical appearance, as described in the novel – “corpus” or “excess weight” – is not respect. Amanda Seyfried seems to be very thinner than the image made by the character.

They emphasize that the difference between the tube and Nina partially goes through physics: the mistress of the house will release, carry the stained glass, leave its obvious roots … under the trailer, written viewers: “It looks like the correct representation of the novel, except that the current Nina is very thin. This is an important point for this plot if you want to protect the book. “ Another add: “Wonderful, besides being Nina’s skinny … it was part of her story. She’s refraining.”

Up RedditThe same criticism returns: “Nina must be overweight. It’s an important feature of her character. The narrator constantly talks about her weight …”

Up X, surfer Even doubt about the choice of actor. “Amanda Seyfried?

Also noticed another item of the trailer: Sabrina Carpenter’s song choice “Please”. With its sincere rhythm and its accents, which are both gentle and disturbing, it perfectly accompanies the first images of the film, emphasizing the mix of mysteries and psychological tension that characterizes history. Surfer also comments on the trailer: The “Please Please” as a trailer song is excellent. Without a spoiler, but if you read a book, you will understand why this song is perfect. “

Thus, the cleaning woman’s trailer stimulates the blend of enthusiasm and debate between the reader of the novel. If the casting and devotion of a certain set are widespread, important differences, such as the pipe room or Nina’s physical, continue talking. Of course, the details, but which is important and arguing that the adaptation of Frida McFadden’s novel is zealously waiting for fans.

Cleaning a woman Let’s go to our rooms on December 24, 2025.