Harry Potter: It’s an inconsistency that irritates fans

Maintaining consistency in a world full of magic that goes beyond the laws of physics is sometimes difficult. The cinematic saga swept the carpet from the second opus, establishing an astonishing rule for the multicellular medicine.

Indeed, from the movie Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Harry and Ron take this potion, allowing them to temporarily take on another human appearance. This requires an element of the human body that you want to copy. In addition, Hermione makes the mistake of taking the drug dose and becomes a cat-woman. As for our two heroes, they use him to look like the congregation and Goyle in every way to find out if Malfoy is Slytherin’s successor.

The problem is that the film establishes that the potion does not reflect the voices of the people who name themselves, forcing Harry and Ron to try to reproduce the voices of Crabbe and Goyle themselves in order to convince their cover Malfoy.

In addition to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Barty Crouch Jr. regularly drinks polythene to identify a mad eye with a mad eye, but his voice is perfectly the kind he got without thinking about imitation. And no one notices, even. Who Moody knows well. And this is where the inconsistency comes in.

JK Rowling had no problem!

In the books, multivitamin medicine is consistent from volume to volume and it is explained that the medicine physically alters the user’s body and therefore their vocal yoga and voice, so that the usurper does not require any imitation ability to be convincing. Once turned into a goy, he can do it even without Harry glasses!

Possible explanations

The first possible explanation, unfortunately, is earthly. Warner’s studio paid Brendan Gleeson for the role of Mad Eye Moody, and did not intend to duplicate David Tennant (Bart’s translator) throughout the film, risking revealing a film reversal. Moreover, we do not know whether David Tennant would have the necessary talent of an imitator.

The second is to imagine that the writers simply wanted to have the cleverness of Harry and Ron as they tried to imitate the congregation and Goyle in order to add a hilarious moment so as not to think about the consequences of using polythene for the rest of the saga.

The third is that the narrative in the books constantly reminds us that Harry and Ron are in the skins of the congregation and Goyle, while in the movies we are simply confronted by comedians who play Crab and Goyle. To remind the viewer – especially the youngest – that cheating is taking place, the idea of ​​retaining the voices of usurping actors may make sense from a technical point of view related to film media.

The latter explanation is more “narrative” and may be due to the dosage of the drug. Maybe Bart, who drinks polythene like water, increased the transformation to the point that he would not have to change his voice?

Note that the soup pot can be seen in other books of the magic franchise. First in Half-Blood Prince, when Congregation and Goyle turn into young girls, then in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, when Harry and his friends enter the Ministry of Magic.

Anyway, this discrepancy between the Secret Chamber and the Cup of Fire remains in the eyes of the fans as they recall every time they watch these two Saga films. An concern that is becoming increasingly unfortunate as the film’s “Chamber of Secrets” is being filmed Fiery bowl Came out and therefore could have been avoided.

Inconsistencies in the agreement, but also false connections: