Why are Lula’s inauguration book and banner different from those used by Bolsonaro?

Why are Lula’s inauguration book and banner different from those used by Bolsonaro?

It is not true that the book in which President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT) signed the mandate and the presidential sash he used during the ceremony are fake, as social media posts claim. The petist signed a different document from his predecessors because the old volume, which contains the signatures of dignitaries from Café Filho (1954-1955) to Jair Bolsonaro (2019-2022), was closed in 2019. Despite being different from the one used by Bolsonaro, the presidential sash worn by Lula is not fake: it had already been used by him in his first inauguration, in 2003.

The publications that reproduced the misleading information amassed at least 10,000 Kwai views, 3,000 Instagram likes and hundreds of Facebook shares on Monday afternoon (2). The content was also disseminated through WhatsApp, a platform whose scope cannot be estimated (talk to Fatima).

Why are Lula’s inauguration book and banner different from those used by Bolsonaro?




The image suggests that Lula signed the warrant in a fake book

Publications on social networks claim that the inauguration book signed by President Lula at the National Congress on Sunday (1st) is fake because it does not have stripes with the color of Brazil, which is not true. As explained on the Federal Senate website, President Lula open the third volume of the Historical Book of the Presidential Inauguration.

The first book had 30 pages and was signed in 1891 by Deodoro da Fonseca, while the second was opened in 1954, with the signature of Café Filho, who took over after the suicide of Getúlio Vargas. The facsimiles of the first two volumes are available, in their entirety, at in the Archive of the Senate.

It is worth mentioning that the opening of a third volume of the document was expected from January 2019. On the last page of the second volume, it can be seen that the then general secretary of the Senate table, Luiz Fernando Bandeira de Mello Filho, has closed the notebook after the inauguration of the former president.



Print shows the closing of the term featured on the last page of the second volume of the history book of presidential and vice presidential inaugurations

Signature. Term present at the end of the document that closes the second volume of the historical book in January 2019 (Reproduction/Acervo Senado)

Lula took the oath as the 39th president of Brazil last Sunday (1st) after winning the election with 60.3 million votes. THE the signature of the term of possession has been digitised and can be seen on the Senate website. The ceremony took place yesterday afternoon and was characterized by two speeches, both verified by Aos Fatos (cf here and here).

Why are Lula’s inauguration book and banner different from those used by Bolsonaro?

The lead is false!



The image compares the presidential banners used by Lula and Bolsonaro to deceptively suggest that the petist has received a fake symbol

In addition to the book, social media users also say that the presidential sash used by Lula during his inauguration is fake, but it’s not true. Although different from the one used by former President Bolsonaro, who was not at the ceremony or handing over the gown, the sash used by Lula is the same one he wore during his first term (2003-2006), with the golden coat of the arms and center with the colors blue and white (see below).



The photo shows the presentation of the presidential sash in January 2003

2002. Fernando Henrique Cardoso delivers the presidential sash to Lula (Reproduction/Folha de S.Paulo)

In 2006 the Planalto opened a tender for the creation of a new presidential sash. The new prop has become used in September 2008during Brazil’s independence celebrations (see below).



The photo shows Lula with the new sash, sold at auction in 2006, next to Cristina Kirchner and Marisa Letícia.

2008. Lula appears for the first time with the new presidential sash (Wilson Dias/EBC).

At the 2011 inauguration, Lula presented Dilma Rousseff (PT) with the latest banner, which displays the red-edged star and leaves of the presidential coat of arms in brighter colors (see below). In 2015, however, the former president presented himself with the old armband, used by Lula in his first term. According to the newspaper The State of Sao Paulo, this happened because the recent presidential sash and its pin would be gone. You objects have been found after.



Comparison shows the banner Dilma received at the 2011 inauguration and the one she used at the 2014 inauguration

Exchange. Dilma received the most recent banner from Lula in 2011, but used the old symbol in 2015 (Fábio Rodrigues Pozzebom/EBC;José Cruz/EBC)

Michel Temer (MDB) wore the presidential sash during Jair Bolsonaro’s inauguration ceremony on January 1, 2019. as you can see in the deeds weather. Because Bolsonaro did not attend Sunday’s ceremony, Lula he chose to use the old trackthe same one he wore during his first term.

Conspiracy theories. The allegations about the book and banner are among the conspiracy theories used to argue that the possession was a forgery. One of them is that the commanders of the Armed Forces did not attend the ceremony, which is not true: General Júlio Cesar de Arruda (Army Commander), Admiral Marcos Sampaio Olsen (future Navy Commander) and Brigadier Marcelo Damasceno (future commander of the Air Force) accompanied the inauguration of Palazzo Planalto.

The false claim that Augusto Heleno was not exempt from the GSI (Institutional Security Office) and that this proves that he was at the head of the country also circulates on the networks. the general he was discharged on December 31st by the then interim president, Antonio Hamilton Mourão (Republicans), as stated in the DOU (Official Gazette).

References:

1. Senate (1, Two, 3 and 4)

Two. to the facts (1 and Two)

3. Stadium (1 and Two)

4. CNN Brazil (1 and Two)

5. UOL (1 and Two)

6. Youtube (Gang journalism)

7. federal government

+The best content in your email for free. Choose your favorite Terra newsletter. Click here!

Source: Terra

You may also like