The judge orders the mouse to demonstrate or represent the accusations against Chico Buarque

The judge orders the mouse to demonstrate or represent the accusations against Chico Buarque


The decision of the 41st Civil Court of Rio requires retraction within five days or the presentation of evidence on the alleged favoritism through Rouanet Law


Summary

Rio’s judge orders Ratinho, Thiago Asmar and Samantha rides to provide accusations against Chico Buarque on the alleged reception of Rouanet’s law resources or with publicly portrayed within five days.

Judge Victor Agustin Cunha Jacucoud states that Torres, from the 41st Civil Court of Rio de Janeiro, determined on Thursday 2, that the presenter Ratinho, YouTuber Thiago Asmar (sacked) and the deputy director Samantha Cavalca (PP-Pi) demonstrate the statements made against the individual and Songwriter Chico Buarto within five days.

The Estadão He searched Ratinho, Thiago Asmar and Samantha Cavalca, as well as the lawyers of Chico Buarque, and awaits the return to update the topic.

The trial was opened after the defendants associated the artist’s political commitment with an alleged receipt of resources by Rouanet’s law. The Estadão He had access to the decision, in which the magistrate stressed that Chico claims to have never obtained public funds from this program of cultural incentives and, therefore, has the right to correct the information.

Freedom of expression x right to honor

The judge recognized that the case involves the collision between two constitutional principles: freedom of expression and protection of honor and privacy. According to him, although political criticism is legitimate and supported by the Constitution, there is no room for the dissemination of false information.

“The actor exercises his right to correct the information that is objectively false. (…) nor could the defendants defend their right to lie – at least the lie in a non -efficiency context, journalistic sedentist or political comment,” he wrote in the decision.

Retraction or test

The magistrate established that the portrait of Topo, Asmar and Cavalca “with the same means of dissemination” used for the declarations, unless they can demonstrate in court that Chico Buarque received appeals from the law of Rouanet or from the management of the workers’ party.

The decision also warns that if the defendants do not respect the order of the court, they could be framed for a crime of disobedience, which, in theory, would justify the arrest in the law.

End and allowance

In the initial action, Chico Buarta asks for compensation for R $ 50 thousand from each defendant. The judge, however, has not yet decided the merits of the financial repair, only on an urgent request. In addition, it has established that the initial petition is modified to clarify whether the singer seeks solidarity or individual condemnation of the accused.

Context of the declarations

The mouse speeches were made on September 15 during the broadcast on Radio Massa FM, his radio station. Together with the criticisms of the singer e Caetano VelosoThe presenter said that the left artists were favored by Rouanet’s law.

Source: Terra

You may also like