Lord of the Rings: This is the question that all fans asked themselves 20 years ago by discovering the king’s return!

“Bad idea. Very practical, this camp helps.”

He saw that Aragorn was released from the army and granted his freedom, and Gimli could not help with his misunderstanding, thus echoing many viewers who found the king’s return to the theaters in December 2003.

Why did Aragorn allow the army?

We are at the end of the terrible battle of Champs Du Pelenor, especially intense, and mostly we won the ghosts of Dunharrow, which rragor went looking for a mountain to go down the road to force them to take their oaths. These warriors, who once accused Isildur (ancestor of Aragorn) and who had no honor for their promise, really condemned for centuries until they made their mistakes.

• Lord of the Rings: What became Aragorn after the king’s return?

Given that during their efficacy in combating the forces of Sauron, we have the right to ask: Why didn’t Aragorn retain them shortly until he was liberated and why he did not ask them to come to Mordor’s door for his last battle?

A very different struggle in books

As it was particularly noted Article from Collider Site On this issue, cases have not really happened in JRR Tolkien’s original works. Indeed, in books, the dead have never left the legs in the battle of Champs du Pelenor. By calling Aragorn, they exclusively served the transfer of a pirate fleet whose heir to his inheritance with his men was able to own Gray’s company after releasing ghosts from the oath.

Between the pages of Tolkien, the dead army was driven long before the land. But the question remains: Why not use this strong asset in the end?

In view of the available information, we can reasonably assume that the oath of the dead participates in one struggle, which is the one in which they have been rejected for centuries. Aragorn was an honorable man, he decided not to use them more.

Risk for the final fight?

In addition, as certain arguments of fans determine, Again the Collider’s article was givenThe presence of ghosts near Sauron (whether it is a nickname nickname and whose spectrum control is known) can be a real threat to the Gondor army and even against it.

What do you think about these arguments? Do you have another to explain Aragorn’s decision?

(RE) Discover the trailer for “King’s Return” …