CBF Crisis: Questions about the skills signs in the Stf agreement and creates instability for Ednaldo

CBF Crisis: Questions about the skills signs in the Stf agreement and creates instability for Ednaldo


The process with the participation of the former vice -president motivates the congress to convene the office to testify; The entity does not manifest itself

The agreement he has maintained Ednaldo Rodrigues in the presidency of Brazilian football confederation (CBF)approved by Supreme Federal Court (STF), passes through a question. Competence indicates that one of the signatures is false. From this, the National Congress He wants to evoke the president to testify, after attempts to fail in the CPI.

The analysis of the experience concerns the signature of Antônio Carlos Nunes de LimaColonel Nunes, former vice president of the CBF, who was the interim president of the entity on two occasions. The inspection was made by the expert Jacqueline Tiretti, at the request of the director of the river Marcos Dias (Somos).

According to the document obtained by EstadãoElements have been observed that differentiate writing. “The belief that can be deduced from all the characteristics observed and considering all the intrinsic limitations to this examination is non -identification of the expert punch of Antônio Carlos Nunes de Lima“Says the text.



The experience questioned the fact that the name was signed on January 19, five days before the actual signature of the agreement, “already giving the prosecutor specific powers to claim the judicial approval of an agreement not existing at the time”.

The analysis mentions that the signatures available for the analysis date back to 2015 at 2023, which, according to the text, compromises the contemporaneity required in the experts of experts. Between 2015 and 2017, Colonel Nunes signed in a simplified way, just like his voice. From 2022, he began to sign with his full name.

Another underlined information is that in June 2023 Nunes informed the Court a cognitive deficit from malignant cerebral neoplasia (brain cancer) and in severe heart disease. Both are serious clinical conditions that require continuous treatment of Nunes since 2018.



Colonel Nunes (left) presided over the CBF Intermediate twice before and one after Rogério Caboclo (right).

The information was presented in a case at the Court of Justice of Pará (TJ-PA). The action was presented by Nunes so that the Institute of Social Security Management and the social protection of the State of Pará (Igepps) had not served a value relating to the foods of his retirement, since he had resumed marriage with his wife, Maria Venina Rosa de Lima.

This is not the first time that a Nunes signature is controversial. In 2021, Colonel’s wife reported to the CBF that Rogério Caboclo stressed Nunes to sign a prosecutor who granted the power to choose his substitute if he was suspended. The former president denied the accusation at that moment.

Maria Venina’s report said that Nunes was under the influence of medicines. The colonel would have signed the power of the prosecutor without knowing the content, two days before undergoing a heart surgery.

At that point, the CBF was already chaired by Ednaldo Rodrigues, based on the Board of Directors, an application formed by vice -presidents. Replaced the same Colonel Nunes.

Although he publicly celebrated the appointment of Ednaldo, Caboclo claimed irregularities and tried to indicate Nunes as a substitute. The colonel, however, expressed to the CBF that he did not have health conditions to take over and who renounced the appointment.

However, two days later, on November 6, 2021, Nunes signed the power of the prosecutor who gave the power of representation to a Lemos Baster Law Firm, appointed by Caboclo.

I am also signatories of the agreement a Federation of the football of Minas Gerais; Castellar NetoJudge of the Fifa Tribune; Fernando SarneyMember of the FIFA Executive Committee; Gustavo FeijóVice President of CBF; and the former president Rogério Caboclo.

Application for signature congress motivated to convene Ednaldo

The requirements ask for public auditions on the agreement that ended a case to the Supreme Court and has maintained the Ednaldo in office. At home, vice sergeant Gonçalves (PL-LN) presented the request

The parliamentarian cites Colonel Nunes, who commanded the entity in a intermediate way on two occasions: between 2017 and 2019, after leaving Marco Polo del Nero, and in 2021, between the removal of the accusation of sexual harassment by Rogério Caboclo and the creation of Ednaldo.

Nunes has been president of the Paraense Football Federation for almost 20 years. It was the cylinder hat that commanded the CBF during the 2018 World Cup in Russia. It was the first command of a military military personnel in a World Cup from the end of the dictatorship.



Nunes was president of the CBF during the Russian World Cup in 2018, when he already had weakened health signs.

At the time, at the age of 80, Colonel Nunes was appointed figurative president. He took, even before, between 2017 and 2019, after the resignation of Marco Polo del Nero, prohibited by football by the FIFA ethical committee for the accusations of corruption.

Del Nunes was chosen by Del Nero to replace him in case of removal and prevent the opponent from the Fim Peixoto from entering in office. Peixoto, who died in 2016 in the air collapse of the Chapecoense plane, was born in 1941, three years after Nunes, who had priority by age criterion.

Colonel Nunes’ health was already a theme of concern at that moment. It was in a 50 -day hospital due to an endocarditis, an inflammation in the heart, due to the bacterial infection.

This is the point mentioned by deputy Gonçalves in the application. The parliamentarian claims that it is necessary to determine the civil capacity of Nunes to sign the agreement that has maintained Ednaldo in the presidency.

The relationship of Estadão He contacted two members of the Colonel Nunes family, including his wife, Maria Venina Rosa de Lima. However, they didn’t want to manifest themselves.

By message, the president of the Paranse Football Federation, Ricardo Gluck Paul, said he had not seen Nunes from the match between Brazil and Bolivia, held in Mangueirão, Belém. The game was valid for the qualifications of the 2026 World Cup on September 8, 2023.

“It is of fundamental importance to ascertain whether the agreement was signed by the free and spontaneous will of Mr. Antonio Carlos Nunes, without the management of the arsenal of pressure, harassment and espionage that marks the current management of the CBF,” wrote Gonçalves in the application.

The text also requires Maria Venina’s call; Ricardo Noneato Macedo de LimaPresident of the Bahiana Football Federation and elected vice president of the CBF; Matheus Senna Silveira do Santos AND João Paulo by Carlo Cone Perezwitnesses of the judicial agreement that guaranteed Ednaldo’s stay; AND Jorge Roberto Paguracurrent head of the CBF medical committee.

At the request of the Senate, deposited by Senator Eduardo Girão (Nova -ce), the facts are mentioned in the April issue of the magazine Piauí. The text of the journalist Allan de Abreu mentioned the lack of transparency in the hiring of lawyers with high expenses and use of CBF resources for personal expenses, such as travel and accommodation of family members, politicians, journalists, magistrates and artists during the Qatar World Cup. 3 million dollars are assigned in these expenses at the 2022 World Cup.

There is still talk of the fact that the speaker of the cause that maintained the Ednaldo in office was Minister Gilmar Mendes, who received the cause for draw. A possible conflict of interest is discussed, as the magistrate is the founder of the Brazilian Institute of Teaching, Development and Research (IDP), which has a commercial partnership for the formations of the CBF Academy.



CBF Academy has a commercial partnership with an educational institution founded by the Minister of Stf Gilmar Mendes.

Another point cited by the request is the list of the CBF with the state federations. Until 2021, each president of the Federation received $ 50 thousand per month. Upon the arrival of Ednaldo, the raises on salaries increased the salaries to $ 215,000 per month, with the sixteenth salary.

“The gravity of the situation lies not only in the accusations themselves, but also on the impact that can have on the credibility of the CBF. The entity, although of a private nature, performs a social function of extreme relevance for the country. The CBF is the football guardian, the national passion that mobilizes millions of Brazilians and transcends the borders, influencing the culture and country of the country.

“The lack of respect for these principles (legality, morality, advertising and efficiency), incorporated into the various irregularities reported, involves the civil liability of the entity. The way in which the CBF is managed, therefore, is not a limited issue to its members, but of public and national interest”, concludes.

Nunes received $ 1.15 million from CBF in 2024

In a declaration of the Nunes income tax, for the year 2024, the income of R $ 1.15 million is underlined, which has the CBF as a paying source. The nature of the value is described as an income without employment.

This description depends on the legal entity to pay the individual, in the case of the title of commissions, intermediation, bonuses, taxes and copyrights, for example.

The CBF has not yet commented on the questions to the agreement approved to the Supreme Court. In the meantime, the Court is preparing to judge the merits of the action on May 28th. In the process, there is a consent on the possibility that the public judicial service will intervene or establish an adjustment of the conduct (CT) with sports entities.

The process, however, will not change the situation of Ednaldo as regards the presidency of the CBF. Recently, it has been re -elected for a new term, unanimously acclaimed by the 27 federations and the 40 Serie A and B. clubs

Source: Terra

You may also like