Foreign: Earth is a good series? Spectators’ separation has returned the verdict!

Since its speech, the new Alien Series: Earth of FX Cable Channel (Senior Display in the United States with the Hulu Platform) leaves no one left indifference. This ambitious production has signed Noah Hokl, who will bring us to the earth in the iconic world created by Ridley Scott, promised to renew the franchise, and respect its terrible DNA.

But what do viewers think? When separation, 83 comments were published, while we write these lines, we express a contrasting portrait of this long series.

Special effects that are unanimous

If a consensus is made between the viewer, it is the visual quality of the alien: the earth. Pierre-Frédéric C, which gives the maximum note to 5/5, is full of praise: “After the very first, I added 5 note, in fact I would say it’s worth a big budget series that they haven’t fixed with us, special effects and various explosions are the best films in the cinema. “

Anne-Valérie Favre (4/5) shares this enthusiasm: “A real surprise! At the same time, after the last few years of films, the bar was not high. According to this, the spirit of the beginnings exists (especially with reference to many and second components).“

But the script makes the teeth

Unfortunately, compliments often stop here. The most viral criticism is aimed at the inconsistency of the script. Ramond David (1/5) will not reduce his words: “On earth, everyone will hear crying! After two time -consuming episodes, I am discerning. The series is poorly done, the scenario is made with inconsistencies, another story about the identity of artificial creatures.“

Romain D. (0.5/5) prevents the saga’s essence from abandoning: “The result: horror and tension, but Saga’s trademark, allowing heroin to hollow dialogues and endless psychoanalysis sessions.“

Disney Shadow on a franchise

Redemption by Fox Disney – by prolonging FX – is crystallized by many frustration. Raphael Benamar (1/5) denies the watered approach: “After seeing the first two episodes, we can conclude that it is alien to Disney audiences: the introduction of super heroes ‘teenagers, often inconsistent protagonists’ decisions.“

Laurent C (2/5) goes farther into criticism: “Disney points to his territory, as well as an animal that would get urine on the franchise, succeeding in the extract of cartoon Peter Pan in the alien world.“

Despite this criticism, some viewers hope. Emilia Kansamu (4.5/5) recognizes: “Wow it was very creative, in any case, well done, though it leaves us for a new season.“Because of the separation, we were amazed at these first episodes, perhaps a little very rich and abundant, but we say that it remains in the future.

Foreign: Earth is available on Disney+ on August 13, with the first two episodes. New episode every Wednesday.